Think You Picked the Wrong Medicare Advantage Plan? Here’s Your Chance to Change

Advertisement.

“I never should have listened to my brother, who bragged about how his Medicare Advantage plan was saving him money and cutting down on his Medicare Supplement Plan premium. I just discovered that the eye doctor scheduled to perform surgery on my right eye in early January is not part of my plan’s network. I realize now that I should have called the doctor’s office before signing up for this HMO plan.

Advertisement.

Now, my eye surgery is postponed because the doctor’s office says I’ll need to return to Original Medicare for the type of surgery I require. Can you explain how and when I can return to Original Medicare? Thankfully, I didn’t cancel my Medicare Supplement Plan G, even though the premium has gone up.” —Christina

If you’ve found yourself in a situation where you’ve chosen the wrong Medicare Advantage (MA) Plan, good news! Starting January 1st, there’s a 3-month window called the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (MA OEP). During this time—from January 1st to March 31st—you can switch to a new Medicare Advantage Plan or return to Original Medicare. If you drop your current MA Plan in January, for instance, your return to Original Medicare will take effect on February 1st.

Advertisement.

You’ll find more information about this on page 72 of the 2025 Medicare & You Handbook. This handbook details what changes can be made during the MA OEP. Keep in mind, though, that the MA OEP is different from the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), which runs from October 15th to December 7th. Importantly, the MA OEP is only available to people already enrolled in a Medicare Advantage Plan. It does not apply to those with Original Medicare or a standalone prescription drug plan (Part D).

After March 31st, anyone enrolled in a Medicare Advantage Plan or Part D drug plan is “locked in” until the AEP in the fall.

This means you won’t be able to make changes or return to Original Medicare until the next AEP!

Why Keeping Your Medicare Supplement Was a Smart Move

Christina, you made a wise decision by not canceling your Medicare Supplement Plan G. Due to your health concerns, you might not qualify for a new Medicare Supplement plan if medical underwriting is required. Many people don’t realize that there’s no special enrollment period for Medicare Supplement policies like there is for Medicare Advantage or Part D plans. You can apply for a Medicare Supplement any time of the year, but your acceptance often depends on meeting medical underwriting requirements.

Advertisement.

For readers, here’s an important tip: Don’t cancel your Medicare Supplement plan during the first few months of trying a Medicare Advantage Plan. This gives you the option to return to Original Medicare during the MA OEP if needed.

How to Avoid This in the Future

At Toni Says Medicare consultations—whether in person or via Zoom—we advise clients to call all their healthcare providers and verify which Medicare Advantage plans they accept before making any changes. This step is vital, as it prevents issues like postponed surgeries, as Christina experienced.

Also, be aware that doctors, specialists, and facilities can stop accepting certain Medicare Advantage plans at any time. It’s always a good idea to confirm coverage with the office manager whenever you’re considering switching plans.

Need Help?

If you need assistance disenrolling from the wrong Medicare Advantage plan and finding a Medicare Supplement Plan that better fits your needs, call the Toni Says Medicare office at 832-519-8664. You can also email your Medicare questions to [email protected]. Don’t be afraid to reach out so you can avoid picking the wrong Medicare Advantage plan and receive the coverage you deserve!

Advertisement.

Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage

Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage are both great options, but they don’t always cover the same things. And honestly, it can be like comparing apples and oranges. Here’s what you need to know about coverage:

Original Medicare: This covers a lot, but it might not cover everything. Think of it as the basic package. You might still have to pay for some things out of your pocket, like copays and deductibles. You’ll also typically need a separate plan to cover your medications (like Medicare Part D).
Medicare Advantage: These plans are like special all-inclusive packages. They usually cover everything Original Medicare covers, plus some extras like vision, hearing, or dental care. But, there can be a catch – you might need to see only doctors who are in the plan’s network.

Original Medicare is great, but some Medicare Advantage plans offer even more. These extras can be really helpful depending on your needs. Here are some examples of bonus features you might find with some Medicare Advantage plans:

Vision care: This can help cover things like eye exams, glasses, or contacts.
Hearing aids: Some plans offer discounts or even help pay for hearing aids.
Dental care: This might cover cleanings, fillings, or even dentures.
Fitness programs: Some plans offer gym memberships or discounts on fitness classes.

BUT…

Not all plans offer these extras. It depends on the specific plan you choose.
There might be extra costs. Some plans might charge more for a plan with additional benefits.

Choosing Between Medicare and Medicare Advantage

Here’s a quick refresher on the 7 sneaky secrets we talked about to help you choose the BEST Medicare plan for you:

Secret #1: Money Matters! Compare costs like premiums, deductibles, and copays for both Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans.
Secret #2: What’s Covered? It’s Not Always the Same! Original Medicare covers a lot, but you might need a separate plan for prescriptions. Medicare Advantage plans often include extras like vision or dental, but have networks of doctors you might need to see.
Secret #3: Who Can You See? With Medicare Advantage, you usually need to see doctors in the plan’s network for the best coverage and the fewest out-of-pocket costs.
Secret #4: Prescription Drugs. Original Medicare might need a separate Part D plan for prescriptions. Medicare Advantage plans often include prescription coverage, but check the plan’s formulary (list of covered drugs) to see if yours are included.
Secret #5: Flexibility or Fences? Original Medicare offers more freedom to choose any doctor, but there might be more rules about coverage and costs. Medicare Advantage plans have networks and might have set costs, but less freedom to choose doctors.
Secret #6: Bonus Features! Some Medicare Advantage plans offer extras like vision, hearing, or dental care. These are great if you need them, but not all plans offer them, and might cost extra.
Secret #7: Timing is Everything! Choosing the Right Enrollment Period! There are specific times to enroll or change plans. The Initial Enrollment Period (IEP) is your first chance to sign up for Medicare to avoid penalties. Open Enrollment happens every year in October and December.